I really wanted to love this project. But if I had to guess, it would be just a fancy FPGA in a good looking case.
Here is what I want regarding the C64 reboot:
1) New C64, C64c, C128, Plus/4, etc. cases made new (we have the C64c now but not sure if they are still being made).
2) New keys being made for the C64/128.
3) VIC-II drop-in replacement via FPGA like the F18A is for the TMS9918. It should work with legacy C64's.
4) Drop-in replacement for the SID. We have the SwinSID but it isn't 100%. The Propeller's SIDCog is VERY good. But it can't act as a drop-in replacement (anyone want to tackle this one??). A drop-in FPGA or Propeller that worked in legacy C64's would be awesome.
5) Drop-in replacements for the various C64 support chips...PLA, CIA, etc.
6) New motherboard for C64 (this is done...but I think very expensive).
That's a tall order but I think all of them could be done. If we had those, then building a C64 compatible would be possible.
And please, don't mention FPGA solutions. Not the same thing. HOWEVER, I admit an FPGA solution at the CHIP LEVEL (like F18A) is OK as long as it is a DROP-IN replacement.
In 2016, you can build a 100% compatible ZX Spectrum with new parts. Let's do the same for the C64.